5 Emails to Transform a Subscriber into a Fan | Yeemel

Photo by Pesce Huang on Unsplash

You just gained 50 new subscribers this week. Great! But in 7 days, 80% of them will have forgotten who you are. The problem? You don't have a welcome sequence to transform them into real fans.

TL;DR: A 5-email welcome sequence can triple your engagement and sales. Here are the exact templates + AI automation to create them without writing.

Why a Welcome Sequence is Essential for Creators#

Photo by Tina Devidze on Unsplash

Creators make a massive mistake: they spend hours creating content to attract new subscribers, but zero minutes welcoming them properly.

The numbers speak for themselves:

• Welcome emails have a 50% open rate (vs 20% for regular emails)
• An onboarding sequence can increase your sales by 30% in the first 90 days
• 74% of new subscribers expect to receive a welcome email immediately

The problem without a sequence:

1. Your new subscribers don't know what to expect
2. They forget why they signed up
3. They perceive you as "just another creator who sells"
4. They unsubscribe or become inactive

The goal of a welcome sequence:

• Create a personal relationship from day one
• Demonstrate your value before selling
• Automate your conversion process
• Transform strangers into an engaged community

The Perfect Timing for a Creator Sequence#

This cadence respects your subscribers' attention rhythm without spamming them.

Email 1: Deliver the Lead Magnet and Introduce Yourself Authentically#

Photo by Pesce Huang on Unsplash

Objective: Keep your promise and create a positive first impression.

Template:

Subject: "Here's your [lead magnet] + who I really am"

"Hi [First Name],

You just downloaded my guide on [topic]. Here it is attached.

But before you dive in, let me introduce myself. My name is [your name], and for [X] years, I've been helping [target audience] achieve [transformation].

Here's what you can expect from my emails: • [Benefit 1] every week • [Benefit 2] without spam • [Benefit 3] with concrete examples

Question for you: what's your biggest challenge with [topic] right now?

Reply directly to this email, I read everything.

[Your first name]"

Key elements:

• Immediate delivery: the lead magnet must be attached or accessible with one click
• Personal introduction: who you are, your experience, your mission
• Clear promises: what they'll receive in your future emails
• Interaction: ask a question to start the conversation
• Personality: write like you'd talk to a friend

Pro tip: Use a photo of yourself in the email (not your logo). People subscribe to people, not brands.

Email 2: Share Your Best Content to Create Engagement#

Photo by Vitaly Gariev on Unsplash

Objective: Demonstrate your value with your strongest content.

Template:

Subject: "My most shared content (and why)"

"Hi [First Name],

I've created over [X] videos/articles on [topic], but there's one that stands out.

It's been shared [X] times and generated [concrete result] for me. Here's why:

[Link to your best content]

In this video/article, you'll discover: • [Key point 1] • [Key point 2] • [Key point 3]

This is exactly the type of content I share every [frequency]. Concrete, tested, actionable.

Check it out and let me know what you think.

[Your first name]

PS: If you have questions after watching, reply to this email. I love exchanging with my community."

Criteria for choosing your "best content":

• Your content with the most engagement (comments, shares)
• A step-by-step tutorial that brings transformation
• A video where you explain a difficult concept simply
• A case study with measurable results

Mistakes to avoid:

• Don't share your most recent content (not necessarily the best)
• Avoid content that's too advanced and might frustrate beginners
• Don't put 5 different links, focus on ONE exceptional piece of content

Email 3: Tell Your Story to Create Emotional Connection#

Photo by Mariia Shalabaieva on Unsplash

Objective: Humanize your brand and create a deep connection.

Template:

Subject: "How I messed up everything (and what it taught me)"

"Hi [First Name],

I'm going to tell you the story I never tell in public.

[X] years ago, I was [starting situation]. I thought [limiting belief] was the solution.

Result? [Failure/difficulty]. I had [negative consequence].

That's when I understood [key lesson]. Instead of [old method], I started [new approach].

6 months later: [transformation result].

Why am I telling you this?

Because I see many [target audience] making the same mistake I did. If you're going through [common difficulty], know that:

1. [Advice 1]
2. [Advice 2]
3. [Advice 3]

You're not alone in this struggle. We've all been there.

[Your first name]"

Effective narrative structure:

1. Starting situation: where you were before
2. Problem/failure: what didn't work
3. Revelation: the breakthrough that changed everything
4. Transformation: the results obtained
5. Lesson: what your audience can take from it

Story topics that work:

• Your first entrepreneurial failure
• The day you almost gave up
• Your worst financial period
• The moment you understood your mission
• A lesson learned from a mentor/failure

Email 4: Prove Your Value with a Concrete Case or Testimonial#

Photo by Vitaly Gariev on Unsplash

Objective: Demonstrate your results with concrete proof.

Template:

Subject: "[Client name] earned [result] in [time] - here's how"

"Hi [First Name],

I'm going to show you a concrete transformation case.

[Client name] was [starting situation]. Their problem? [main obstacle].

In [duration], here's what happened:

📈 Before: [starting metrics] 📈 After: [results obtained]

How did we do it?

Step 1: [Concrete action 1] Step 2: [Concrete action 2] Step 3: [Concrete action 3]

The most important thing? [Key success factor].

"[Direct client testimonial]" - [Client Name]

What's crazy is that [Client name] wasn't different from you. Same [similarity with your audience], same [common challenge].

The difference? [Differentiating element of your method].

[Your first name]

PS: If you want similar results, I have something that might interest you... I'll tell you about it in my next email."

Alternatives if you don't have clients yet:#

Credibility elements:

• Precise numbers (not "much better" but "+47%")
• Clear timeline (in how much time)
• Screenshot or photo of the result
• Testimonial with first name (and photo if possible)

Email 5: Offer Your Product Without Being Intrusive#

Objective: Sell naturally after providing value.

Template:

Subject: "You asked me how to do the same..."

"Hi [First Name],

Following my email yesterday about [client case], I received 15 messages with the same question:

"How can I get the same results?"

I thought this might interest you too.

Here's the truth: [Client case] didn't get these results by magic. He/she followed a precise system I developed over [duration].

This system is exactly what I share in [your product/service].

Concretely, you'll learn: • [Specific benefit 1] • [Specific benefit 2] • [Specific benefit 3]

It's the same method [client case] used to [result].

[CTA Button: "I want the same results"]

Price: [Price] (instead of [crossed out price] if you're running a promo)

Why am I offering this to you now?

Because you've been part of my community for [duration]. You've read my emails, you've seen the results I get. If you're ready to take action, now is the time.

Questions? Reply to this email.

[Your first name]

PS: [Guarantee or bonus if applicable]"

Soft selling techniques:

• Social proof: "Following the questions I received..."
• Logic: connect the offer to the previous case study
• Gentle urgency: "if you're ready to take action"
• Reassurance: guarantee or ability to ask questions

Sales mistakes to avoid:

• Going from 0 sales to big promo in the same email
• Using salesy language ("exceptional offer", "last chance")
• Forgetting to connect the offer to the value already provided

How to Automate Your Welcome Sequence with Content Generated from Your Videos#

Writing 5 quality emails can take 8-10 hours. What if you could generate them automatically from your existing videos?

The Yeemel Method in 4 Steps:#

Step 1: Identify Your Best Videos Spot 5 of your videos that correspond to each email's objectives:

• Email 1: video where you introduce yourself or explain your mission
• Email 2: your most popular tutorial
• Email 3: video where you tell your journey
• Email 4: client testimonial or case study
• Email 5: presentation of your product/service

Step 2: AI Generation With Yeemel's newsletter generation tool, paste each YouTube video URL. The AI generates 4 newsletter versions per video, with different angles and tones.

Step 3: Personalization Adapt each generated newsletter:

• Configure your tone (direct, educational, storytelling according to the email)
• Add personal elements (name, experience, specific details)
• Integrate your products naturally in email 5

Step 4: Automation Schedule your sequence in the tool:

• Email 1: immediate send after subscription
• Emails 2-5: automatic delays (D+2, D+5, D+8, D+12)
• Targeting by list or tag according to subscription source

Advantages of this approach:#

Pro tip: If you don't have 5 videos that correspond exactly, you can record 10-15 minute audios specifically for your sequence. The AI will transform them into professional emails.

Measuring and Optimizing Your Sequence: Metrics That Matter#

A welcome sequence without measurement is wasted time. Here are the essential KPIs:

Main Metrics to Track:#

Open Rate by Email:

• Email 1: 60-70% (very high because recent)
• Email 2: 45-55% (still engaged)
• Email 3: 35-45% (normal drop)
• Email 4: 30-40% (qualified audience)
• Email 5: 25-35% (interested in the offer)

Click Rate by Email:

• Email 1: 15-25% (high curiosity)
• Email 2: 20-30% (valuable content)
• Email 3: 10-20% (emotional connection)
• Email 4: 15-25% (social proof)
• Email 5: 5-15% (purchase intent)

Global Unsubscribe Rate:

• Target: <5% on the entire sequence
• If >8%: your content isn't aligned with expectations
• If >15%: major problem with promise or quality

Optimizations to Test:#

A/B Testing on Subjects:

• Email 1: "Here's your guide" vs "Guide + who I really am"
• Email 2: "My best content" vs "Why this video changed my life"
• Email 5: "How to do the same" vs "You asked me how..."

Timing:

• Test D+1, D+3, D+7 instead of D+2, D+5, D+8
• Adjust send time according to your audience (9am vs 2pm vs 7pm)

Length:

• Short version (150-200 words) vs long version (400-500 words)
• Single CTA vs multiple options

Simple Tracking Dashboard:#

Warning Signs:

• Brutal drop in open rate (>20% between two emails)
• Unsubscribe rate >3% on a single email
• Click rate <10% on email 2 (your best content)
• Zero conversions on email 5

FAQ#

How long after subscription should I send the first email?#

Immediately or within 5 minutes maximum. New subscribers are in a state of high attention right after subscribing. Waiting several hours drastically reduces engagement.

What should I do if I don't have client testimonials yet?#

Use your own transformation journey, positive comments on your content, or results from a method you tested. Authenticity trumps quantity of social proof.

Should I adapt the sequence according to subscription source?#

Yes, ideally. A subscriber from a "beginner" lead magnet doesn't have the same expectations as a subscriber from an advanced webinar. Create 2-3 sequences according to your main traffic sources.

How do I know if my sequence is working well?#

Look at the global conversion rate: how many new subscribers become customers within 30 days? A good target is 2-5% for a digital product, 10-15% for a premium service.

Can we shorten the sequence to 3 emails?#

It's possible but less effective. The 5 emails allow you to create a real relationship before selling. If you want to shorten, keep emails 1, 2, and 5, but you'll lose the emotional connection and social proof aspects.

An effective welcome sequence transforms strangers into fans, then into customers. With these 5 templates and AI automation, you can create yours in a few hours instead of several days.

The most important thing? Getting started. Even an imperfect sequence that sends automatically is better than the best emails sitting in your drafts.

Want to automate your welcome sequence without writing? Try Yeemel for free and transform your videos into emails that convert.